Study number | Author (year) | Abstract and title | Intro and aims | Method and data | Sampling | Data analysis | Ethics and bias | Results | Transferability | Implications and usefulness | Total quality assessment score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Abrahamsson (2005) [19] | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | 32 |
2 | DeWilde (2015) [27] | Fair | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Poor | Fair | 25 |
3 | Everett (2005) [28] | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | 28 |
4 | Longman (2018) [29] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Poor | Good | Good | Good | 34 |
5 | Randall (2009) [30] | Fair | Very Poor | Poor | Poor | Poor | Good | Fair | Poor | Poor | 21 |
6 | Rezk-Hanna (2018) [47] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | 36 |
7 | Reardon (2016) [26] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Poor | Good | 34 |
8 | Bull (2007) [22] | Poor | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | 22 |
9 | Colomar (2015) [48] | Good | Good | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair | Good | Poor | Fair | 28 |
10 | Herberts (2012) [49] | Good | Good | Poor | Fair | Fair | Poor | Fair | Poor | Fair | 26 |
11 | Aquilino (2003) [23] | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | 28 |
12 | Thomson (2019) [25] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | 35 |
13 | Thomson (2019) [21] | Good | Fair | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Poor | Fair | 31 |
14 | Ashwin (2010) [31] | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | 29 |
15 | Bovill (2018) [33] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Good | Good | Good | 35 |
16 | Bowker (2015) [34] | Good | Fair | Fair | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | 33 |
17 | Britton (2017) [35] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | 34 |
18 | Butterworth (2014) [36] | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair | Fair | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | 30 |
19 | Gamble (2015) [37] | Fair | Fair | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Good | 27 |
20 | Goszczyńska (2016) [38] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | 33 |
21 | Haslam (2001) [39] | Poor | Fair | Fair | Poor | Poor | Poor | Fair | Poor | Fair | 22 |
22 | Haugland (1996) [42] | Fair | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | Very Poor | Fair | Fair | Fair | 27 |
23 | Hotham (2002) [40] | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Poor | Fair | Poor | 26 |
24 | Howard (2013) [41] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | 35 |
25 | Lendahls (2002) [43] | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair | 28 |
26 | Naughton (2013) [44] | Fair | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair | 31 |
27 | Naughton (2018) [51] | Good | Fair | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | 33 |
28 | Petersen (2009) [45] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Good | Good | 35 |
29 | Wiggington (2013) [46] | Good | Fair | Poor | Fair | Fair | Fair | Good | Fair | Fair | 28 |
30 | Wood (2008) [50] | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Fair | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | 32 |
31 | Bar-Zeev (2019) [24] | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | 35 |
32 | Reeks (2020) [20] | Good | Good | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | Fair | Good | 29 |