From: Psychosocial risk factors for postpartum depression in Chinese women: a meta-analysis
First author | Year | study sites | Sample size | PPD Group | Assessment method | Quality scores | Investigate time | Risk factors |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lee [18] | 2004 | Hong Kong | 781 | 122 | EPDS | 8 | first trimester/ 6 weeks postpartum | (1),(5) |
Zhao [19] | 2018 | Shanghai | 215 | 67 | EPDS | 7 | late pregnancy/ week 3-days and 6-weeks after delivery | (1) |
Pan [20] | 2004 | Sichuan | 427 | 33 | EPDS | 6 | third trimester/ 4 ~ 6 weeks postpartum | (1),(3) |
Zhao [21] | 2018 | Sichuan | 1440 | 25 | EPDS | 6 | third trimester/ 8,18 weeks postpartum | (1) |
Siu [18] | 2012 | Hong Kong | 805 | 126 | EPDS | 7 | third trimester/ around 2 months postnatally | (4),(5) |
Li [22] | 2017 | Shanxi | 1759 | 593 | EPDS | 6 | third trimester/ 4 weeks postpartum | (4),(6) |
Gu [23] | 2004 | Shanghai | 999 | 307 | HADS | 6 | Second trimester/ 4 weeks postpartum | (3),(4) |
Sun [24] | 2015 | Yunnan | 528 | 96 | EPDS | 6 | third trimester/ 4 weeks postpartum | (6) |
Kang [25] | 2015 | Jiangsu | 3972 | 468 | EPDS> 10 | 6 | first trimester/ 6 weeks postpartum | (6) |
Dennis [26] | 2017 | Canadian immigrants | 549 | 120 | EPDS> 9 | 8 | third trimestery/ 4 weeks postpartum | (6) |
Cai [27] | 2017 | Chongqing | 371 | 60 | EPDS≥13 | 7 | Second trimester/ 6 weeks postpartum | (6) |
Hu [28] | 2010 | Sichuan | 264 | 146 | EPDS> 9 | 6 | Second trimester/ 4 weeks postpartum | (4) |
Gu [29] | 2017 | Xinjiang | 824 | 286 | EPDS> 13 | 6 | 42 days postpartum | (1),(2) |
Zhang [30] | 2017 | Guangdong | 538 | 49 | EPDS> 10 | 7 | 42 days postpartum | (1),(2) |
Wu [31] | 2019 | Guangdong | 1437 | 100 | EPDS> 10 | 6 | 4 weeks postpartum | (1),(2) |
Shen [32] | 2011 | Shanxi | 104 | 52 | EPDS> 13 | 6 | 4 weeks postpartum | (1) |
Yang [33] | 2016 | Hubei | 400 | 37 | EPDS> 13 | 6 | 4 ~ 6 weeks postpartum | (1),(3),(8) |
Zhang [34] | 2001 | Tianjin | 463 | 47 | EPDS≥13 | 7 | 4 weeks postpartum | (4) |
Yin [35] | 2011 | Guangdong | 202 | 37 | SDS > 40 | 5 | 4 weeks postpartum | (3),(4) |
Huang [36] | 2012 | Hunan | 302 | 56 | EPDS | 6 | 6 ~ 7 weeks postpartum | (4) |
Song [37] | 2012 | Hunan | 285 | 69 | SDS | 5 | 4 weeks postpartum | (3),(4),(5) |
Wang [38] | 2013 | Beijing | 435 | 27 | SCL-90 > 2 | 6 | 42 days postpartum | (4) |
Lin [39] | 2014 | Zhejiang | 2023 | 204 | EPDS | 5 | 42 days postpartum | (4) |
Zhou [40] | 2014 | Hubei | 378 | 294 | EPDS/SDS | 5 | 4 ~ 6 weeks postpartum | (4) |
Wang [41] | 2014 | Guizhou | 875 | 112 | EPDS | 7 | 42 days postpartum | (3),(4),(8) |
Chen [42] | 2017 | Zhejiang | 380 | 260 | EPDS> 13 | 7 | 42 days postpartum | (4),(8) |
Jiang [43] | 2018 | Shandong | 185 | 25 | EPDS | 5 | 6 weeks postpartum | (4) |
Han [44] | 2018 | Henan | 248 | 124 | EPDS> 10 | 5 | 4 weeks postpartum | (4) |
He [45] | 2019 | Zhejiang | 398 | 217 | SDS EPDS | 5 | 4 weeks postpartum | (4) |
Yu [46] | 2010 | Shanghai | 673 | 73 | EPDS | 7 | 6 weeks postpartum | (3),(7) |
Zhang [47] | 2012 | Hunan | 215 | 67 | EPDS> 13 | 6 | 30 ~ 42 days postpartum | (7) |
Zhang [48] | 2014 | Guangdong | 586 | 87 | EPDS> 13 | 6 | 6 weeks postpartum | (7) |
Li [49] | 2014 | Anhui | 687 | 103 | EPDS | 7 | 6 weeks postpartum | (3),(7) |
Liu [50] | 2015 | Hunan | 232 | 43 | EPDS/HAD | 5 | 42 days postpartum | (7) |
Liu [51] | 2015 | Heilongjiang | 576 | 162 | EPDS | 6 | 42 days postpartum | (6),(7) |
Chen [52] | 2018 | Northwest China | 640 | 84 | EPDS> 13 | 6 | 6 weeks postpartum | (7),(9) |
Wang [53] | 2013 | Shandong | 917 | 168 | EPDS/SDS | 5 | 6 weeks postpartum | (3) |
Li [54] | 2019 | Shanxi | 170 | 85 | SDS | 5 | 6 weeks postpartum | (3),(6) |
Guan [55] | 2012 | Inner Mongolia | 246 | 92 | EPDS> 9 | 6 | 30 ~ 42 days postpartum | (9) |
Zhang [56] | 2011 | Hubei | 479 | 167 | BDI > =5 | 6 | 7 ~ 30 days postpartum | (9) |
Deng [57] | 2014 | Guangdong | 2021 | 158 | CES-D > 20 | 6 | 42 days postpartum | (5) |
Deng [4] | 2014 | Guangdong | 1823 | 499 | EPDS> 13 | 7 | 4 weeks postpartum | (5) |
Han [58] | 2015 | Beijing | 203 | 189 | EPDS> 13 HAD> 9 | 6 | 42 days postpartum | (5),(8) |
Liu [59] | 2017 | Guangdong | 418 | 93 | EPDS> 9.5 | 5 | 4 ~ 6 weeks postpartum | (5) |
Zhou [60] | 2019 | Jiangsu | 849 | 142 | EPDS> 10 | 6 | 2 ~ 6 weeks postpartum | (5) |
Liu [61] | 2015 | Hubei | 1427 | 198 | EPDS≥9 | 5 | 42 days postpartum | (6),(8) |
Xie [62] | 2018 | Hubei | 534 | 103 | EPDS | 6 | 6 weeks postpartum | (6) |
Pan [63] | 2015 | Zhejiang | 745 | 93 | EPDS | 5 | 42 days postpartum | (2) |
Yang [64] | 2020 | Jiangxi | 371 | 94 | EPDS | 6 | 42 days postpartum, third trimester, | (3),(4),(9) |
Huang [65] | 2020 | Jiangsu | 784 | 59 | EPDS | 6 | 42 days postpartum | (3) |
Qing [66] | 2020 | Guangdong | 522 | 90 | EPDS | 7 | 2nd to 4th postnatal months | (9) |