Skip to main content

Table 8 Sensitivity analysis including missing data

From: Conditional cash transfers to improve use of health facilities by mothers and newborns in conflict affected countries, a prospective population based intervention study from Afghanistan

 

Number (%) of mothers in intervention villages

Number (%) of mothers in control villages

Crude mean difference (95% CI)

P value

Adjusted mean differencea (95% CI)

P value

Facility delivery quintile 3

 Excluding missing data

  

n = 878

 

n = 801

 

 Baseline (n = 455)

190/290 (65.5%)

99/165 (60.0%)

    

 Endline (n = 423)

149/200 (74.5%)

153/223 (68.6%)

    

 Difference

9.0%

8.6%

0.4% (−0.12–0.13)

0.954

−3.0% (− 0.27–0.20)

0.781

 Including missing data

n = 739

n = 660

n = 1399

 

n = 1256

 

 Baseline (n = 621)

245/377 (65.0%)

132/224 (58.9%)

    

 Endline (n = 798)

259/362 (71.6%)

283/436 (64.9%)

    

 Difference

6.6%

6.0%

0.6% (−0.98–0.11)

0.912

−0.5% (− 0.18–0.17)

0.951

 Excluding missing data

n = 353

n = 384

n = 872

 

n = 800

 

 Baseline (n = 448)

179/287 (62.4%)

151/161 (93.8%)

    

 Endline (n = 424)

174/201 (86.6%)

143/223 (64.1%)

    

 Difference

24.2%

−29.7%

53.9% (0.43–0.64)

< 0.001

58.0% (0.23–0.94)

0.004

 Including missing data

n = 739

n = 655

n = 1394

 

n = 1256

 

 Baseline (n = 595)

233/376 (62.0%)

205/219 (93.6%)

    

 Endline (n = 799)

282/363 (77.7%)

285/436 (65.4%)

    

 Difference

15.7%

−28.2%

43.9% (0.35–0.53)

< 0.001

49.4% (0.21–0.77)

0.003

PNC quintile 3

 Excluding missing data

n = 482

n = 383

n = 865

 

n = 791

 

 Baseline (n = 444)

142/282 (50.4%)

115/162 (71.0%)

    

 Endline (n = 421)

163/200 (81.5%)

133/221 (60.2%)

    

 Difference

31.1%

−10.8%

41.9% (0.30–0.54)

< 0.001

45.8% (−0.47–096)

0.071

 Including missing data

n = 732

n = 652

n = 1384

 

n = 1245

 

 Baseline (n = 591)

177/372 (47.6%)

166/219 (75.8%)

    

 Endline (n = 793)

250/360 (69.4%)

252/433 (58.2%)

    

 Difference

21.8%

−17.6%

39.4% (0.29–0.50)

< 0.001

49.8% (−0.01–1.00)

0.054

CHW home visiting quintile 3

 Excluding missing data

n = 489

n = 377

n = 866

 

n = 790

 

 Baseline (n = 456)

142/291 (48.8%)

66/165 (40.0%)

    

 Endline (n = 410)

73/198 (36.9%)

61/212 (28.8%)

    

 Difference

−11.9%

−11.2%

−0.7% (−0.14–0.12)

0.916

−2.8% (− 0.60–0.55)

0.917

 Including missing data

n = 740

n = 642

n = 1382

 

n = 1239

 

 Baseline (n = 599)

184/380 (48.4%)

111/219 (50.7%)

    

 Endline (n = 783)

130/360 (36.1%)

99/423 (23.4%)

    

 Difference

−12.3%

−27.3%

15.0% (0.04–0.25)

0.005

16.0% (−0.49–0.81)

0.596

  1. aAdjusted for clustering by district, maternal age, parity, maternal education, quintile and access to health facilities