Skip to main content

Table 1 ‘Practical Expressions of Rigour’ [26]

From: “Engaging with birth stories in pregnancy: a hermeneutic phenomenological study of women’s experiences across two generations”

Practical expression of rigour

Characteristics of expression

Application in study

Balanced integration

Intertwining of philosophical concepts in methods and findings Balance between the voices of participants and philosophical explanation

Philosophical framework described in methods and applied in findings The researcher’s voice, that of the participants and phenomenological notions give voice to the experience

Openness

Systematic, explicit process of accounting for decisions made throughout study

Transparent audit trail of decision making in relation to design and evolution of the study

Concreteness

Usefulness for practice of study findings

Implications for practice and study limitations discussed

Resonance

Experiential or felt effect of study findings upon the reader

Resonance acknowledged at conference presentations

Actualisation

Future realization of the resonance of the study findings

Acceptance of papers at peer reviewed conferences