Skip to main content

Table 4 Restricted ‘lower risk’-based model (18 studies and 8 systematic reviews)

From: Antenatal care trial interventions: a systematic scoping review and taxonomy development of care models

Category

Description

Restricted risk-based provision:

Principal paper from RCT

First author; year; [country of study]; * indicates sibling paper(s) – see relevant reference list; (SR1 etc. if included in a related systematic review)

Systematic Reviews associated with this category

Midwifery-led interventions

 (n = 12 principal papers, 8 ‘sibling’ papers and 5 SRs)

 (see Additional file 1 reference list T4-1)

Studies where the main focus was on the impact of antenatal care delivered by midwives, or a comparison of midwifery-led care with another mode/model of delivery

Begley 2011 [Ireland] (SR2,3)

Biro 2000 [Australia] * (SR2,3)

Flint 1989 [UK - England] (SR2,3,4)

Giles 1992 [Australia] (SR8,9)

Gu 2013 [China]

Harvey 2002 [Canada] (SR2)

Hicks 2003 [UK - England] (SR2,3)

Homer 2001 [Australia] * (SR2,3,7)

McLachlan HL 2012 [Australia] (SR3)

Turnbull 1996 [UK - Scotland] *** (SR2,3,4,8,9)

Waldenstrom 1994 [Sweden] **

Waldenstrom 2000 [Australia] * (SR2,3)

2 Devane et al. 2010

8 Khan-Neelofur et al. 1998

3 Sandall et al. 2013 –

9 Villar et al. 2007

4Waldenstrom et al. 1998

Reduced/flexible visit interventions

 (n = 6 principal papers, 1 sibling paper and 4 SRs)

 (see Additional file 1 reference list T4-2)

Models investigating whether reduced or flexible antenatal visits had an impact on maternal/infant outcomes

Henderson 2000 [UK – England]

Jewell 2000 [UK – England]

McDuffie 1996 [USA] * (SR5,8,9,10)

Sikorski 1996 [UK – England] (SR5,8,9,10)

Tucker 1996 [UK – Scotland] (SR8,9)

Walker 1997 [USA] (SR5,8,9,10)

5 Carroli et al. 2001

10 Dowswell et al. 2010

8 Khan-Neelofur et al. 1998

9 Villar et al. 2007

Multiple foci

(n = 1 SR)

 (see Additional file 1 reference list T4-3)

 

N/A

7 Yakoob et al. 2009 – interventions that impact on stillbirth