Midwifery-led antenatal care models: mapping a systematic review to an evidence-based quality framework to identify key components and characteristics of care

Symon, Andrew; Pringle, Jan; Cheyne, Helen; Downe, Soo; Hundley, Vanora; Lee, Elaine; Lynn, Fiona; McFadden, Alison; McNeill, Jenny; Renfrew, Mary J; Ross-Davie, Mary; van Teijlingen, Edwin; Whitford, Heather; Alderdice, Fiona

doi:10.1186/s12884-016-0944-6

Table 2 Midwifery-led RCTs: level of published evidence in Intervention arm [Control arm] of characteristics of maternity/newborn care identified in QMNC framework

From: Midwifery-led antenatal care models: mapping a systematic review to an evidence-based quality framework to identify key components and characteristics of care

	Key to scores: 0 = not present; 1 = mentioned, not detailed; 2 = discussed in some detail
	Practice categories			Practice categories		Organisation of care				Values		Philosophy			Care providers
Author, Year	Education info HP	Assessment screening planning	Normal process, complication prevention	Complication referrals	Medical obstetric neonatal services	Organisation of care	Resources	Competent Sustainable workforce	Integration	Respect, Communicate	Tailoring	Optimising	Women’s capability	Intervention use	Knowledge skills	Roles skill mix	Total scores
1 Begley 2011 [67]	0 [0]	2 [1]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [1]	2 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [1]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [2]	14 [7]
2 Biro 2003 [41]	1 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	2 [2]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	19 [5]
3 Flint 1989 [27]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	18 [0]
4 Giles 1992 [28]	2 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [1]	11 [5]
5 Gu 2013 [29]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	2 [2]	1 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	1 [1]	25 [3]
6 Harvey 2002 [30]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [1]	0 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	14 [2]
7 Hicks 2003 [31]	0 [0]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [2]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [1]	2 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	0 [1]	15 [5]
8 Homer 2001 [37]	2 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	2 [1]	2 [0]	2 [1]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [1]	16 [5]
9 McLachlan BK 2000 [40]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [2]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	18 [3]
10 McLachlan HL 2012 [23]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	0 [2]	0 [1]	2 [1]	0 [0]	2 [0]	2 [1]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	15 [5]
11 Rowley 1995 [48]	1 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	10 [0]
12 Tracy 2013 [32]	2 [1]	2 [1]	2 [0]	2 [1]	2 [1]	2 [2]	1 [1]	1 [1]	2 [1]	2 [1]	2 [1]	2 [1]	1 [1]	2 [1]	0 [0]	2 [1]	27 [15]
13 Turnbull 1996 [65]	1 [0]	2 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [1]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	2 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	21 [5]
14 Waldenström 2000 [72]	1 [0]	1 [1]	0 [1]	1 [1]	1 [1]	1 [2]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [0]	2 [1]	2 [1]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	15 [10]
15 Waldenström 1994 [35]	0 [0]	1 [1]	2 [1]	1 [1]	1 [1]	2 [2]	2 [2]	0 [0]	2 [1]	2 [0]	1 [1]	2 [0]	1 [0]	2 [1]	1 [1]	1 [1]	21 [13]
16 Walker 2013 [33]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [1]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	9 [1]
17 Wu 2010 [34]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	1 [0]	1 [0]	1 [1]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	0 [0]	1 [0]	10 [2]
Studies reporting this characteristic	11 [1]	10 [5]	14 [2]	13 [8]	14 [7]	17 [15]	15 [4]	10 [2]	16 [10]	10 [4]	12 [3]	11 [1]	8 [1]	15 [2]	12 [2]	15 [10]

Back to article page

ISSN: 1471-2393

Contact us

Submission enquiries: bmcpregnancyandchildbirth@biomedcentral.com
General enquiries: ORSupport@springernature.com

BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth

Contact us