Seasonal ambient air pollution correlates strongly with spontaneous abortion in Mongolia
BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth volume 14, Article number: 146 (2014)
Air pollution is a major health challenge worldwide and has previously been strongly associated with adverse reproductive health. This study aimed to examine the association between spontaneous abortion and seasonal variation of air pollutants in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia.
Monthly average O3, SO2, NO2, CO, PM10 and PM2.5 levels were measured at Mongolian Government Air Quality Monitoring stations. The medical records of 1219 women admitted to the hospital due to spontaneous abortion between 2009–2011 were examined retrospectively. Fetal deaths per calendar month from January-December, 2011 were counted and correlated with mean monthly levels of various air pollutants by means of regression analysis.
Regression of ambient pollutants against fetal death as a dose–response toxicity curve revealed very strong dose–response correlations for SO2 r > 0.9 (p < 0.001) while similarly strongly significant correlation coefficients were found for NO2 (r > 0.8), CO (r > 0.9), PM10 (r > 0.9) and PM2.5 (r > 0.8), (p < 0.001), indicating a strong correlation between air pollution and decreased fetal wellbeing.
The present study identified alarmingly strong statistical correlations between ambient air pollutants and spontaneous abortion. Further studies need to be done to examine possible correlations between personal exposure to air pollutants and pregnancy loss.
Over the last decades, numerous studies have confirmed a positive relation between air pollution and morbidity and mortality [1–4]. Air pollution has previously been strongly associated with adverse reproductive health. Several studies have examined the effects of air pollution on pregnancy, providing evidence that exposure to ambient air pollutants is associated with poor birth outcome, such as low birth weight [5–7], small for gestational age [8–10], preterm birth [11–14], congenital malformations [15–17] and pregnancy complications such as preeclampsia . In contrast, limited data are available on toxic effects of air pollution on pregnancy loss. Previous studies have shown that environmental tobacco smoke is associated with an increased risk of spontaneous abortion [19–21]. One retrospective epidemiological study provided evidence for an association between brief exposure to high levels of ambient particulate matter during the preconceptional period and early pregnancy loss and found a 2.6-fold increased risk of spontaneous miscarriage . More recent investigations in China  and Iran  also reported an increased risk of fetal loss in early pregnancy during exposure to high levels of air pollutants. However, no report has yet addressed associations between ambient air pollution and pregnancy loss in Mongolia.
Ulaanbaatar (UB), Mongolia is one of the most air polluted capital cities in the world, with ambient sulfide dioxide (SO2) and particulate matter (PM)10 and PM2.5 levels >23 times World Health Organization (WHO) standards in winter . Despite its extraordinarily high air pollution concentrations, UB has received very little research attention, where 623 deaths attributable to air pollution representing 4.0% of the annual deaths for the entire country . Yet its air quality becomes relatively clean in summer. This is because UB is also the coldest capital city in the world, so that air pollution in wintertime is largely caused by coal burning in Ger stoves for domestic heating [25, 27–29]. Moreover, a recent World Bank report relates that these noxious levels of winter air pollution are associated with adverse health effects including cardiovascular events as well as pulmonary diseases that are estimated to cost as much as 19% of UB’s GDP .
Herein, we examined the association between spontaneous abortion and seasonal variation of air pollutants measured near the National Center for Maternal and Child Health (NCMCH), which provides the majority of public obstetric and gynecological services in UB.
The medical records of 1219 women residing near the Bayangol district and admitted to the hospital due to spontaneous abortion between 2009–2011 were de-identified and examined retrospectively. The information collected included maternal age, history of previous pregnancy, while the presence of other serious medical or systemic conditions were excluded. Spontaneous abortion or fetal death was defined as absence of fetal heartbeat detected by ultrasound prior to 20 weeks of gestational age. Pregnancies ending after that period of gestation were considered to be stillbirths and were excluded.
Monthly average ozone (O3), SO2, nitrogen dioxide (NO2), carbon monoxide (CO), PM10 and PM2.5 levels were measured at City Monitoring Agency’s stations located in the Bayangol district near the NCMCH as indices of monthly average ambient air pollution in that district of UB. Air pollutant levels above the reference levels defined by WHO  were considered to be potentially harmful.
Spontaneous abortions that occurred from 2009 to 2011 were recorded and expressed as a percentage of all gynecological admissions, as well as analyzed by maternal age. Fetal deaths per calendar month from January-December, 2011 were counted and correlated with mean monthly levels of various air pollutants by means of regression analysis using Excel. Results are expressed as r coefficients with statistical significance accepted with p < 0.05.
Approval for data collection was obtained from the Ethical Review Board at NCMCH and did not require consent to be sought from participants. Personal information was not collected (including the names of mothers or babies, birth dates, addresses, and phone numbers). No further ethics approval was required for the analyses reported here.
Spontaneous abortion as a proportion of gynecological admissions at NCMCH were consistent over the 3 year period 2009–2011, ranging between 14 and 16% of gynecological admissions per annum (Figure 1A).
Fetal death was distributed evenly across maternal age, reflecting the age distribution of child bearing in the general population (Figure 1B).
In 2011, NCMCH delivered 10,208 babies, while spontaneous abortions totaled 517 (52:1000 live births). However, spontaneous abortion incidence per calendar month ranged over more than 3.6-fold from 20 (23:1000) in May to 75 (73:1000) in December, 2011, revealing a striking seasonal pattern of variation.
Monthly average ambient levels of air pollutants including O3, CO, NO2, SO2, PM10 and PM2.5 versus WHO air quality guidelines are shown in Table 1. Air pollutant emission was relatively much lower during summer time (June-August) but increased strikingly during the winter months (November-February).
Thus, there was a striking seasonal variation in these mean pollutant levels, which correlated closely with advancing and receding hours of darkness over the annual solar cycle (Figure 2A,B,C,D,E).
Regression of ambient pollutants against fetal death as a dose–response toxicity curve revealed very strong dose–response correlations for SO2 r > 0.9, p < 0.001, while similar strongly significant correlation coefficients were found for NO2 (r > 0.8), CO (r > 0.9), PM10 (r > 0.9) and PM2.5 (r > 0.8), (p < 0.001), indicating an alarming, strongly toxic dose–response correlation between air pollution and fetal death due to spontaneous abortion (Figure 3A,B,C,D,E).
The present study has identified alarmingly strong statistical correlations between seasonal ambient air pollutants and pregnancy loss. Previous studies in China have examined the association between spontaneous abortion before 26 weeks of gestation, and found an increased rate in areas with an elevated mean annual level of hydrogen sulfide (>4 μg/m3) . A time-series study in Brazil  likewise found a strong association between stillbirth and both NO2 as an individual pollutant and an index that combined NO2, CO, and SO2. Spontaneous abortion has also been associated with environmental tobacco smoke, which contains many of the same chemical pollutants as traffic exhaust [19, 20]. An association between ambient CO and both carboxyhemoglobin and nucleated red blood cells, signs of fetal hypoxia, has been previously reported in the venous cord blood of newborns . These levels of CO may interfere with tissue oxygenation levels in the fetus, possibly leading to fetal death, as has been demonstrated in animal models . A recent retrospective case control study in Tehran demonstrated that CO was more toxic with respect to spontaneous abortion than other pollutants, while no significant effect was identified for SO2. In contrast, other studies have concluded that exposure to high levels of SO2 and total suspended particulate (TSP) but not PM10 and NO2 during the first month of pregnancy was associated with increased risk of fetal loss . In our study, SO2 and CO were more strongly correlated with spontaneous abortion compared to other pollutants. Methodological differences, different geographic and environmental locations affecting factors such as temperature and humidity, as well as different levels of industrialization might explain the variation between these somewhat different results. Although the studies discussed above reported different results in relation to correlation of specific air pollutants with pregnancy loss, all of them have shown that air pollutants have a strong correlation with spontaneous abortion.
Limitations of our study include its retrospective design and the limited nature of pollution observations with respect to peak intradiurnal variation and geographical distribution within UB [28, 29]. We did not have available meteorological information on humidity and temperature, but nevertheless we showed that change of air pollutants levels increases in relation to the duration of the hours of darkness. Moreover, because of the retrospective design we were limited in terms of ascertainment of additional biological factors related to spontaneous abortion or fetal death that could be potential confounding factors that might have biased the results.
The Ministry of the Environment and Green Development of the Government of Mongolia, in collaboration with the Millennium Challenge Project and World Bank has made major policy strides in recent years in curbing air pollution, reportedly by as much as 30% in 2013 versus 2011 in some central areas of UB, chiefly by the distribution of up to 120,000 more efficient Ger heating stoves, plus Ger clearance programs. The term Ger refers to the traditional round felt tent used as a portable residence by nomadic Mongolian people. Yet, the disturbingly strong correlation between air pollution indices and fetal death we report herein suggests that much more needs to be done to further ameliorate the toxic effects of air pollution on the human unborn.
As has been noted above, the majority of air pollution in UB occurs in winter and is due to coal burning for domestic heating in Gers and wooden houses within the Ger districts, to ameliorate the extreme cold [25, 27–29]. Marked diurnal variation in PM10 levels also have been noted previously and have been correlated with stove lighting in the morning and evening, as well as stoking during the early part of the night. We and our colleagues in government and academia in Mongolia are expending concerted efforts to improve stove efficiency and to educate the public about correct and more efficient lighting and stoking procedures to supplement stove replacement efforts. Interestingly, our unpublished observations show that diurnal PM10 levels drop significantly during the afternoon and early morning. Moreover, inter-diurnal variation in peak PM10 exposure is quite marked during the winter months and this is thought to be inversely related not only to atmospheric temperature but also to wind speed. Additionally, ambient PM10 exposure is known to be much higher within Ger districts than within built up apartment neighborhoods, while NO2 exposure is highest near major traffic thoroughfares [25, 27]. This raises the critical question of whether the toxic dose–response relationship between a panel of pollutants including CO, NO2, SO2, PM2.5 and PM10 and fetal death noted here in UB as a whole, is due to average or peak levels of exposure to one or more pollutants or a combination of these adverse conditions. Presently personal exposure monitoring is beginning to be carried out in selected representative populations, including pregnant women, to attempt to answer some aspects of these questions about the dose-toxicity response characteristics of ambient pollution.
Arguably and alarmingly our data suggest that the strong correlation we have identified between ambient levels of air pollutants and spontaneous abortion in UB may also obtain elsewhere in the world, where similarly deleterious levels of air pollution exist. We speculate that up to 5-fold further reduction in air pollutants in winter will be needed to reduce fetal death rates 4-fold back to levels found in summer in UB. Moreover, even in summer the level of spontaneous abortion is unacceptably high. We plan to continue evaluating personal exposure to air pollutants to determine further deleterious effects on health, including adverse pregnancy outcome.
DE designed the study, analyzed data and co-wrote the manuscript. NW analyzed data and prepared tables and figures. BJ, JU, YK collected and tabulated data with preliminary data analysis. SL, SE oversaw pollution data collection and quality control. DW oversaw the project and co-wrote the manuscript. All authors approved the final manuscript.
National Center for Maternal and Child Health
World Health Organization.
Burnett RT, Brook JR, Yung WT, Dales RE, Krewski D: Association between ozone and hospitalization for respiratory diseases in 16 Canadian cities. Environ Res. 1997, 72: 24-31. 10.1006/enrs.1996.3685.
Burnett RT, Brook J, Dann T, Delocla C, Philips O, Cakmak S, Vincent R, Goldberg MS, Krewski D: Association between particulate-and gasphase components of urban air pollution and daily mortality in eight Canadian cities. Inhal Toxicol. 2000, 12 (suppl 4): 15-39.
Pope CA, Burnett RT, Thun MJ, Calle EE, Krewski D, Ito K, Thurston GD: Lung cancer, cardiopulmonary mortality, and long-term exposure to fine particulate air pollution. JAMA. 2002, 287: 1132-1141. 10.1001/jama.287.9.1132.
Samet JM, Dominici F, Curriero FC, Coursac I, Zeger SL: Fine particulate air pollution and mortality in 20 US cities. N Engl J Med. 2000, 343: 1742-1749. 10.1056/NEJM200012143432401.
Maisonet M, Bush TJ, Correa A, Jaakkola JJ: Relation between ambient air pollution and low birth weight in the Northeastern United States. Environ Health Perspect. 2001, 109: 351-356. 10.1289/ehp.01109s3351.
Ritz B, Yu F: The effect of ambient carbon monoxide on low birth weight among children born in southern California between 1989 and 1993. Environ Health Perspect. 1999, 107: 17-25. 10.1289/ehp.9910717.
Pedersen M, Giorgis-Allemand L, Bernard C, Aguilera I, Andersen AM, Ballester F, Beelen RM, Chatzi L, Cirach M, Danileviciute A, Dedele A, Eijsden M, Estarlich M, Fernández-Somoano A, Fernández MF, Forastiere F, Gehring U, Grazuleviciene R, Gruzieva O, Heude B, Hoek G, de Hoogh K, van den Hooven EH, Håberg SE, Jaddoe VW, Klümper C, Korek M, Krämer U, Lerchundi A, Lepeule J, et al: Ambient air pollution and low birthweight: a European cohort study (ESCAPE). Lancet Respir Med. 2013, 1 (9): 695-704. 10.1016/S2213-2600(13)70192-9.
Parker JD, Woodruff TJ, Basu R, Schoendorf KC: Air pollution and birth weight among term infants in California. Pediatrics. 2005, 115: 121-128.
Srám RJ, Binková B, Rössner P, Rubes J, Topinka J, Dejmek J: Adverse reproductive outcomes from exposure to environmental mutagens. Mutat Res. 1999, 428: 203-215. 10.1016/S1383-5742(99)00048-4.
Liu S, Krewski D, Shi Y, Chen Y, Burnett RT: Association between gaseous ambient air pollutants and adverse pregnancy outcomes in Vancouver, Canada. Environ Health Perspect. 2003, 111: 1773-1778. 10.1289/ehp.6251.
Xu X, Ding H, Wang X: Acute effects of total suspended particles and sulfur dioxides on preterm delivery: a community-based cohort study. Arch Environ Health. 1995, 50: 407-415. 10.1080/00039896.1995.9935976.
Brauer M, Lencar C, Tamburic L, Koehoorn M, Demers P, Karr C: A cohort study of traffic-related air pollution impacts on birth outcomes. Environ Health Perspect. 2008, 116: 680-686. 10.1289/ehp.10952.
Suh YJ, Kim H, Seo JH, Park H, Kim YJ, Hong YC, Ha EH: Different effects of PM10 exposure on preterm birth by gestational period estimated from time-dependent survival analyses. Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 2009, 82: 613-621. 10.1007/s00420-008-0380-7.
Llop S, Ballester F, Estarlich M, Esplugues A, Rebagliato M, Iñiguez C: Preterm birth and exposure to ambient air pollutants during pregnancy. Environ Res. 2010, 110: 778-785. 10.1016/j.envres.2010.09.009.
Smrcka V, Leznarová D: Environmental pollution and the occurrence of congenital defects in a 15-year period in a south Moravian district. Acta Chir Plast. 1998, 40: 112-114.
Rankin J, Chadwick T, Natarajan M, Howel D, Pearce MS, Pless-Mulloli T: Maternal exposure to ambient air pollutants and risk of congenital anomalies. Environ Res. 2009, 109: 181-187. 10.1016/j.envres.2008.11.007.
Dadvand P, Rankin J, Rushton S, Pless-Mulloli T: Ambient air pollution and congenital heart disease: a register-based study. Environ Res. 2011, 111: 435-441. 10.1016/j.envres.2011.01.022.
Dadvand P, Figueras F, Basagaña X, Beelen R, Martinez D, Cirach M, Cirach M, Schembari A, Hoek G, Brunekreef B, Nieuwenhuijsen MJ: Ambient air pollution and preeclampsia: a spatiotemporal analysis. Environ Health Perspect. 2013, 121: 1365-1371.
George L, Granath F, Johansson AL, Annerén G, Cnattingius S: Environmental tobacco smoke and risk of spontaneous abortion. Epidemiology. 2006, 17: 500-505. 10.1097/01.ede.0000229984.53726.33.
Windham GC, Von Behren J, Waller K, Fenster L: Exposure to environmental and mainstream tobacco smoke and risk of spontaneous abortion. Am J Epidemiol. 1999, 149: 243-247. 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a009798.
Chatenoud L, Parazzini F, di Cintio E, Zanconato G, Benzi G, Bortolus R, La Vecchia C: Paternal and maternal smoking habits before conception and during the first trimester: Relation to spontaneous abortion. Ann Epidemiol. 1998, 8: 520-526. 10.1016/S1047-2797(98)00017-9.
Perin P, Maluf M, Czeresnia C, Januario D, Saldiva P: Effects of exposure to high levels of particulate air pollution during the follicular phase of the conception cycle on pregnancy outcome in couples undergoing in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer. Fertil Steril. 2010, 93: 301-303. 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2009.06.031.
Hou HY, Wang D, Zou XP, Yang ZH, Li TC, Chen YQ: Does ambient air pollutants increase the risk of fetal loss? A case–control study. Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2014, 289: 285-291. 10.1007/s00404-013-2962-1.
Moridi M, Ziaei S, Kazemnejad A: Exposure to ambiebt air pollutants and spontaneous abortion. J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2014, 40: 743-748. 10.1111/jog.12231.
Guttikunda SK, Lodoysmaba S, Bulgansaikhan B: Particulate pollution in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Air Qual Atmos Health. 2013, 6: 137-150. 10.1007/s11869-011-0154-3.
Allen RW, Gombojav E, Barkhasragchaa B, Byambaa T, Lkhasuren O, Amram O, Takaro TK, Janes CR: An assessment of air pollution and its attributable mortality in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Air Qual Atmos Health. 2013, 6: 137-150. 10.1007/s11869-011-0154-3.
World Bank: Air quality analysis of Ulaanbaatar: improving air quality to reduce health impacts. Main Report. 2011, http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/2011/12/15580103/air-quality-analysis-ulaanbaatar-improving-air-quality-reduce-health-impacts-vol-1-2,
Huang YK, Luvsan ME, Gombojav E, Ochir C, Bulgan J, Chan CC: Land use patterns and SO2 and NO2 pollution in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. Environ Res. 2013, 124: 1-6.
Warburton D, Gilliland F, Dashdendev B: Environmental pollution in Mongolia: effects across the lifespan. Environ Res. 2013, 124: 65-66.
WHO: Air quality guidelines for particulate matter, ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide. Summary of risk assessment. Global Update. 2005, http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/78638/E90038.pdf,
Hemminki K, Niemi ML: Community study of spontaneous abortions: relation to occupation and air pollution by sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and carbon disulfide. Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 1982, 51: 55-63. 10.1007/BF00378410.
Pereira LA, Loomis D, Conceicao GM, Braga AL, Arcas RM, Kishi HS: Association between air pollution and intrauterine mortality in São Paulo, Brazil. Environ Health Perspect. 1998, 106: 325-329.
Ziaei S, Nouri K, Kazemnejad A: Effects of carbon monoxide air pollution in pregnancy on neonatal nucleated red blood cells. Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol. 2005, 19: 27-30. 10.1111/j.1365-3016.2004.00619.x.
Singh J, Scott LH: Threshold for carbon monoxide induced fetotoxicity. Teratology. 1984, 30: 253-257. 10.1002/tera.1420300212.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2393/14/146/prepub
Supported in part by National Institutes of Health Fogarty International Center/ National Institutes of Environmental Health Award 1D43ES0228620 to DW
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Enkhmaa, D., Warburton, N., Javzandulam, B. et al. Seasonal ambient air pollution correlates strongly with spontaneous abortion in Mongolia. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 14, 146 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2393-14-146